Choosing the Right Apple Watch: A Comprehensive Guide

Choosing an Apple Watch used to be straightforward; you simply decided between the larger or smaller model. However, with the introduction of optional cellular connectivity, a more affordable Watch SE (now in its second generation), and the rugged Apple Watch Ultra (also now in its second generation), the selection has expanded significantly.

Now that the Series 10 has been available for nearly a year, older versions of the Apple Watch are frequently discounted as retailers aim to clear their inventory. Additionally, refurbished versions of these older models are becoming more common. If you are interested in premium materials, such as stainless steel, this is an excellent opportunity to acquire a more luxurious version of last year’s watch. You will not be missing out on much, as recent years have seen mostly iterative hardware updates, with the majority of new features stemming from software updates. However, it is important to note that the latest version of watchOS, watchOS 11, does not support the Series 4, 5, and first-generation SE models.

How We Test Apple Watches

Apple Watches offer a variety of functionalities, from health and fitness tracking to managing notifications. Our testing process involves a combination of year-round experiential assessments and benchmarks. While we may not intentionally drop the watch, we will observe whether a fall during a walk activates the Fall Detection feature. We also evaluate the accuracy of sleep tracking, heart rate monitoring, and GPS against long-term control devices, such as the Oura Ring or Garmin. Furthermore, we compare the various Apple Watch models based on durability, performance, and battery life.

Who Is It For?

We do not recommend the Apple Watch Ultra for individuals who lead a sedentary lifestyle—unless they prioritize battery life above all else. Our goal is to help you select the right Apple Watch tailored to your specific needs.

Price

Should you opt for a new model? Purchasing refurbished can often lead to savings on an Apple Watch, particularly since there are typically minimal changes from year to year.

Feature Set

Are you willing to pay extra for LTE connectivity? Which models include specific sensors, and how do those features align with your requirements?

LTE or GPS

In certain situations, opting for cellular models is necessary, while in others, GPS alone suffices.

Buying refurbished can be a viable option to upgrade from an older model without sacrificing blood oxygen monitoring. Due to a patent dispute with Masimo, new Series 9 and Ultra 2 models sold in the US after January 18, 2024, no longer have this feature. This may not be significant for most users, but if it is a priority for you, older watches and Series 9 and Ultra 2 units sold by Apple before January 18, 2024, will still include this feature. (This restriction only affects units sold in the US.)

Regarding the newer Series 10, it features a larger display, is approximately 10 percent thinner, and is lighter than its predecessors. It also introduces a new FDA-cleared sleep apnea detection capability. Additionally, there are numerous new colors and finishes, with titanium replacing stainless steel. Overall, while it is an iterative update, we find it significant in terms of readability and wearability.

The abundance of choices can lead to analysis paralysis. However, rest assured that I have tested every available version of the Apple Watch—along with basically every other fitness watch and smartwatch on the market—and can guide you in the right direction.

Recommended Models

1. Should you get an Apple Watch?
2. Apple Watch Series, SE, or Ultra?
3. The best Apple Watch if you’re on a budget
4. The best Apple Watch for kids
5. The best Apple Watch for older relatives

Should You Get an Apple Watch?

The Apple Watch is regarded as the best overall smartwatch for iPhone users. While many smartwatches may outperform the Apple Watch for serious athletes, other models often lack in productivity, safety features, smart home control, and integration with other Apple devices and services. The Apple Watch boasts the most extensive third-party app ecosystem of any smartwatch available.

Wearables are inherently personal devices, and you will not reap the benefits of an Apple Watch if you do not wear it consistently. The last thing you want is to invest hundreds of dollars in a device that ends up gathering dust in a drawer. To mitigate this risk, prioritize comfort when selecting your watch. Before deciding on which Apple Watch model to purchase, take a moment to determine which size and strap material will best suit your wrist.

The SE and Series watches are available in two sizes each. The SE is offered in 40mm and 44mm, while the Series 7, 8, and 9 come in 41mm and 45mm. The new Series 10 increases the size to 42mm and 46mm. Larger models enhance readability, while smaller ones provide greater comfort for individuals with petite wrists. Both the SE and Series watches feature aluminum cases, but the Series 10 is now available in titanium as well. (Older models are made of stainless steel.) Most users will find aluminum sufficient, but if you are prone to accidents or lead an active lifestyle, the added durability of stainless steel or titanium may be beneficial. Additionally, personal preference regarding aesthetics is valid, as watches are a personal piece of technology. Just be prepared to pay a premium for that choice.

For straps, we recommend the nylon sport loop, as it is the most breathable option, features the easiest clasp, and is less irritating than silicone alternatives, making it ideal for sensitive skin. If you are seeking more fashionable options, consider exploring Amazon or Etsy for a broader range of styles at more affordable prices. Additionally, check third-party vendors for leather accessories, as Apple announced in 2023 that it would cease production of leather accessories in an effort to achieve carbon neutrality.

The Ultra and Ultra 2 models are available in a single size—49mm—and feature titanium cases. They come with specialized straps: the Trail Loop, Alpine Loop, and Ocean Band. As their names imply, these straps are designed for runners, hikers, and divers, but you can choose whichever one appeals to you. We recommend the Trail Loop for its lightweight and versatile design. All Ultra straps are compatible with any 44mm or 45mm Series watch, and the Ultra is also compatible with any 44mm or 45mm Apple Watch strap.

While the Apple Watch is the premier smartwatch for iPhone users, you can also explore our fitness tracker buying guide.

Apple Watch Series, SE, or Ultra?

The latest Apple Watch,